Canadian telecom M&A risks a costly encore
TU•Quebecor proposed buying Telus in a deal valued at C$60.6 billion, including net debt, but Telus has rebuffed the offer. The analysis estimates a 6.7% return on investment, below Telus’ 7.6% weighted average cost of capital.
1. Returns fall short
Quebecor’s proposed acquisition of Telus is valued at C$60.6 billion, including net debt, and Telus has rebuffed the offer. Including C$160 million in estimated operating cost savings, Telus would generate a little over C$4 billion in net operating profit after tax for 2027, based on Visible Alpha data. The estimated 6.7% return on investment is below Telus’ 7.6% weighted average cost of capital.
2. Debt and execution risks
Roughly two-thirds of the offer is in stock. Quebecor expects to reduce leverage to 3.5 times EBITDA from 4.1 times within two years by cutting stock buybacks and capital expenditures. Rogers Communications’ 2023 acquisition of Shaw offers a cautionary comparison: analysts now expect Rogers to reach its debt-to-EBITDA target about three years late.
3. Possible asset sales
An investor in both companies pointed to Telus’ digital unit, its health business and rural fiber networks as potential divestitures that could generate perhaps C$10 billion. The analysis estimates that sales within a year could lift returns closer to 8%, but says the margin would remain thin. The proposal also faces potential regulatory roadblocks, and Telus’ special committee identified significant regulatory and execution risks.




