Expert’s AI prompts in environmental lawsuit must be disclosed, US judge rules
SHEL•A US federal judge ruled that an expert for an environmental group suing a Shell Oil subsidiary must disclose prompts used to produce her witness report.
1. Prompts must be disclosed
US District Judge Vernon Oliver in Connecticut affirmed a magistrate’s decision requiring Naomi Oreskes to turn over AI prompts she or her team used to sort documents for a witness report prepared for Conservation Law Foundation. Oliver said the prompts comprised “the basis” for her opinions and were distinguishable from notes on draft material that might be shielded from disclosure.
2. Lawsuit over flooding risks
The lawsuit alleges that a Shell terminal in New Haven, Connecticut, risks exposing nearby neighborhoods and waterways to hazardous chemicals during flooding. Shell has denied wrongdoing. The ruling is part of a growing number of disputes over whether expert witnesses must disclose AI prompts.




