For investors, a truly safe haven is hard to find
TLT•Recent selloffs have shown that Treasuries, gold and currencies do not always protect portfolios when stocks fall. Finance professor Campbell Harvey says no single asset is a dependable all-weather hedge, and suggests combining assets and strategies.
1. Hedges depend on the shock
Assets that typically cushion portfolios can fall alongside stocks when volatility is driven by inflation, geopolitical risk or liquidity concerns. In April 2025, tariff fears sent long-dated Treasuries lower as yields rose; the start of the US-Israeli war with Iran on February 28 also lifted oil and bond yields on inflation concerns. Gold fell with stocks in late October and touched a one-year low.
2. No single safe haven
Treasuries remain highly liquid and can attract investors during risk-off periods, but can decline with stocks when inflation and Federal Reserve tightening are concerns. Harvey called Treasuries the world’s bellwether safe asset, while noting that stocks and bonds have increasingly moved in the same direction and the diversification benefit of a 60% stocks, 40% bonds portfolio has decreased. He cited US debt of $40 trillion, annual deficits of about $2 trillion and annual interest payments of $1.1 trillion.
3. Combine defensive tools
Gold can be reliable over centuries, Harvey said, but its annualized volatility is above 15%, similar to the S&P 500’s, and it can fall during short periods. Currency havens also have weaknesses: the yen is sensitive to oil prices, while the dollar offers safety and yield, with Treasuries paying a 4.5% coupon. Harvey said gold, Treasuries, commodities, inflation-adjusted Treasuries and active strategies such as quality and trend-following approaches may work better in combination than alone.




