For investors, a truly safe haven is hard to find
SPY•Recent selloffs have shown that Treasuries, gold and currencies do not always cushion portfolios when stocks fall. A Duke finance professor said no single asset is a dependable all-weather hedge, and combining defensive assets and strategies may improve the chance a portfolio works.
1. Hedges depend on the shock
Recent market declines have exposed how assets traditionally seen as safe havens can fall alongside stocks. Treasuries sold off during tariff-related volatility in April 2025 as yields rose, while oil and bond yields climbed after the February 28 start of the US-Israeli war with Iran. Gold also fell with stocks in late October, touching a one-year low.
2. Different risks, different havens
Treasuries may attract investors in a risk-off mood, but can decline alongside stocks when inflation or Federal Reserve tightening is the concern. Campbell Harvey, a finance professor at Duke University's Fuqua School of Business, said diversification benefits from the traditional 60% stocks and 40% bonds portfolio have decreased. He cited US debt of $40 trillion, annual deficits of about $2 trillion and annual interest payments of $1.1 trillion.
3. No single all-weather hedge
Harvey said gold can be reliable over centuries but volatile over shorter periods; its annualized volatility is above 15%, similar to the S&P 500's. Currency havens also have drawbacks, while the dollar offers safety and yield, said Steve Englander of Standard Chartered Bank. Harvey said defensive portfolios can combine gold, Treasuries, commodities, inflation-adjusted Treasuries and active strategies such as trend-following and quality approaches.




