Health insurers fell for a second consecutive session after CMS proposed tighter audits and other measures targeting fraud and improper payments. Morgan Stanley estimated potential repayments could equal 11% to 51% of its 2028 earnings estimates for UnitedHealth, Humana and CVS, while calling the impact highly uncertain.
UnitedHealth shares fell 9.6%, Humana dropped 11.3% and Elevance Health declined 6.9%. Molina Healthcare fell 4.9%, Centene 6.7%, CVS Health 4.29% and Cigna 3.3%.
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services proposed expanding audits of Medicare Advantage plans and increasing scrutiny of deductions from payments to Medicaid insurers. Morgan Stanley said the proposal could substantially increase repayments by allowing errors found in audit samples to be applied to the wider population represented by those samples.
Morgan Stanley estimated potential repayments could equal 11% to 51% of its 2028 earnings estimates for UnitedHealth, Humana and CVS. It said the impact remains highly uncertain and expects industry pushback.