Palomar’s Gray Surety Acquisition and E&S Premium Growth Signal Q4 Outperformance

PLMRPLMR

Palomar acquired Gray Surety, expected to reduce its exposure to the Property & Casualty cycle and improve the companywide loss ratio. Excess & Surplus premium growth in certain states for December 2025 and 4Q25 suggests potential Q4 outperformance when Q4 results release next month.

1. Technical Breakout Signals Bullish Momentum

On January 5, Palomar (PLMR) printed a decisive move above its 200-day moving average, closing at that level on volume 35% above its 30-day average. This marks the first sustained breach of this key long-term trend line since mid-2024 and suggests that institutional buyers may be stepping in. Over the past three months, PLMR has built a series of higher lows, and this breakout coincides with a Relative Strength Index reading near 62, indicating room for further upside before reaching overbought territory. Investors tracking momentum indicators will note that the stock’s 50-day moving average has moved within 5% of the 200-day, raising the possibility of a golden-cross formation in the weeks ahead.

2. Acquisition of Gray Surety Enhances Underwriting Profile

Palomar closed its acquisition of Gray Surety on December 15, 2025, in a transaction valued at $120 million in cash and stock. Gray Surety’s niche in professional liability and surety bonds is expected to lower Palomar’s exposure to adverse swings in the broader Property & Casualty cycle, improving the consolidated loss ratio by an estimated 150 basis points over the next four quarters. Management projects at least $15 million in annualized cost synergies by consolidating back-office operations and leveraging combined reinsurance treaties. The deal also adds a $300 million premium base that carries an average combined ratio below 90, compared with Palomar’s current companywide ratio near 94.

3. Favorable Industry Trends Point to Q4 Upside

Recent data for December 2025 show Excess & Surplus (E&S) premium growth of 8.2% year-over-year across key states—California, Texas and Florida—versus a 4.5% gain in the standard P&C segment. This outperformance in E&S pricing and underwriting capacity should flow through to Palomar’s Q4 earnings, due in mid-February. Analysts covering the name have raised fourth-quarter underwriting margin estimates by an average of 30 basis points since the Gray Surety announcement, with consensus projecting a 12% increase in quarterly net premiums written. Should Palomar outperform by even a few percentage points, it may signal further upward revisions heading into the first quarter.

Sources

SZ