Renter-to-homeowner transition rate falls 46% since 2009, TransUnion finds
TRU•TransUnion found the renter-to-homeowner conversion rate fell to 3.9% in 2025 from 7.2% in 2009. Small-business applications have topped 500,000 monthly since late 2025, while 83% of small-business owners want to shop for insurance online and 32% do so.
1. Homeownership transition declines
TransUnion's analysis found the renter-to-homeowner conversion rate fell to 3.9% in 2025 from 7.2% in 2009, a 46% decline that shrinks the pool of new homeowners insurance policyholders and intensifies competition for customers. Migration toward states with greater catastrophic-weather exposure also raises risks for homeowners insurers.
2. Commercial insurance trends
Small-business applications have exceeded 500,000 monthly since late 2025, expanding commercial insurance opportunities. While 83% of small-business owners want to shop online, only 32% do so. Commercial auto insurers face profitability pressure from rising loss costs, retiring drivers and diesel prices that constrain fleet maintenance spending.




