Supreme Court to Hear Bayer Appeal and Stock Jumps 6.6% on Nubeqa Outlook
The US Supreme Court has agreed to hear Bayer's appeal to sharply limit Roundup cancer lawsuits, potentially averting billions of dollars in liability damages. Bayer shares rallied 6.6% after partner Orion forecast that Nubeqa sales could exceed $1 billion over the long term.
1. Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Bayer’s Bid to Curb Roundup Lawsuits
On Friday, the U.S. Supreme Court granted Bayer’s request to review lower-court rulings that have allowed tens of thousands of plaintiffs to pursue claims alleging that Roundup causes non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Bayer has argued that federal pesticide law preempts these state-level tort actions, a legal theory that, if accepted, could bar or sharply limit future lawsuits. To date, Bayer has set aside more than $25 billion for Roundup-related settlements and judgments, and the company faces roughly 95,000 pending claims in U.S. courts. A successful appeal could prevent Bayer from having to allocate additional billions to satisfy verdicts and settlements in jurisdictions that have been favorable to plaintiffs.
2. Litigation Costs Have Weighed on Bayer’s Financial Results
Since acquiring Monsanto in 2018 for $63 billion, Bayer’s earnings have been under pressure from Roundup litigation expenses. In its most recent annual report, the company reported $7.5 billion in legal provisions for weed-killer claims in the prior fiscal year alone, contributing to a 12% decline in core earnings before interest and taxes for the Crop Science division. Analysts estimate that each 10,000-case reduction in pending claims could improve Bayer’s adjusted operating profit by approximately €500 million. Investors will closely watch the Supreme Court’s timetable for oral arguments and decision, which could arrive by mid-2027.
3. Stock Surges on Positive Nubeqa Forecast
Shares of Bayer surged 6.6% following an announcement by oncology partner Orion that long-term global sales of Nubeqa, a prostate cancer therapy co-developed with Bayer, could exceed €1 billion annually. Bayer retains tiered profit-sharing rights, entitling it to roughly 30% of net revenues once Orion’s manufacturing and commercialization costs are recouped. Nubeqa generated €350 million in revenue for Bayer in the past twelve months, and is approved in over 50 markets. Management has signaled that successful Phase III trials in earlier-stage prostate cancer could unlock an additional €200 million in annual sales by 2028.
4. Broader Pharma Strategy Supports Growth Outlook
Beyond Nubeqa, Bayer is advancing a pipeline of over 60 mid- to late-stage assets across oncology, cardiology and women’s health. The company recently completed a €3 billion acquisition of a rare disease specialist, adding two clinical-stage gene therapies targeting hemophilia A and Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Bayer forecasts that these assets could contribute up to €2.5 billion in combined annual sales by 2030. Coupled with expected relief from Roundup-related liabilities, management projects a compound annual growth rate in adjusted earnings per share of 8% to 10% through the end of the decade.