UnitedHealth sues US government over lowered Medicare Advantage star ratings
UNH•UnitedHealth sued the US government over 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, saying CMS improperly used 26 measures to rate 45 contracts. The company said correcting the ratings would raise them by 0.5 to 1.5 stars.
1. Challenge to ratings
UnitedHealth said CMS lacked authority to use 26 measures for ratings across 45 contracts, or failed to give the company a chance to object. It said the ratings could deprive it of bonus payments and lower patient benefits, and that improperly low ratings could limit preventive care and increase premiums.
2. Medicare Advantage impact
Higher-rated plans can receive government bonus payments reaching hundreds of millions or billions of dollars if costs stay low. UnitedHealth served about 7.61 million Medicare Advantage patients as of September 30 and holds a 30% market share, according to the American Medical Association. CVS Health and Humana have also sued over ratings; a federal judge in Georgia ordered CMS to recalculate a Clover Health rating in May.



