US court skeptical of Missouri's lawsuit over Starbucks DEI policies
SBUX•A three-judge 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals panel appeared skeptical that Missouri can sue Starbucks over alleged discrimination tied to its diversity, equity and inclusion policies. A lower court dismissed the state's lawsuit in February because it did not identify any Missouri resident allegedly harmed.
1. Appeals panel questions claims
The panel heard Missouri's appeal of a ruling dismissing its 2025 lawsuit against Starbucks. Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway alleges the company tied executive pay to racial and gender hiring quotas and offered training and advancement opportunities to preferred groups; the state says thousands of Missourians may have been affected.
2. Starbucks disputes state authority
The judges questioned why Missouri had not identified specific people allegedly discriminated against. Starbucks lawyer James Bennett argued that the state was seeking powers beyond those recognized by courts and could not enforce federal civil rights statutes while bypassing requirements imposed on the federal government. Missouri seeks an end to the alleged practices, employee reinstatements, rescinded discipline and unspecified damages.
3. Related cases
Starbucks settled a Florida discrimination lawsuit in September by pledging not to adopt race- or sex-based quotas or preferences in hiring, promotion and pay decisions; the company has denied having such policies. A federal judge dismissed a shareholder lawsuit challenging Starbucks' diversity policies in 2023.




