Recent White House moves underscore these limitations.
On Monday, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent expanded sanctions against Tehran and threatened secondary measures against countries continuing to do business with it, describing the campaign as an "economic D-Day."
Yet sanctions are unlikely to deliver breakthroughs, and threats of secondary sanctions hold little weight when Bessent has made clear that Washington seeks to avoid actions that could seriously upset the global economy.
That reduces the likelihood that the U.S. will impose severe penalties on China, Tehran's largest oil customer – one of the few economic measures that could move the needle with Iran.
Washington is also attempting to jawbone markets by arguing that oil flows through Hormuz are recovering rapidly despite Iranian threats.
Over the past week, senior White House officials have argued that Gulf exports are approaching pre-war levels as more tankers depart under U.S. naval protection, with their transponders turned off. Energy Secretary Chris Wright said on Friday that the seven-day average for oil leaving Hormuz had climbed above 8 million bpd.
However, shipping analytics firms monitoring Hormuz through satellite imagery and vessel-tracking data see little evidence of a recovery.
Oil exports through the strait have averaged just 2.2 million bpd so far in August, according to Kpler. Total regional crude exports, including shipments from Saudi and Emirati ports that bypass Hormuz, averaged about 9 million bpd this month, down from 11 million bpd in July and roughly 17 million bpd in 2025.
While the administration may be seeking a deal behind the scenes, the contrast between Washington's public claims and the data suggests desperation rather than strength.
The longer the conflict drags on, the harder it becomes for Trump to argue it is succeeding. The Islamic government remains in power, Hormuz remains constrained, fuel prices remain elevated and economic costs continue to mount.
The U.S. possesses overwhelming economic and military power but little appetite for a wider war. Iran is economically weakened, yet has demonstrated a willingness to absorb extraordinary pain to pursue strategic goals. The conflict is therefore a contest of endurance rather than manoeuvre.
Despite what Trump and Bessent argued this week, U.S. economic pressure resembles the grinding trench warfare that kept World War One going far more than the decisive Allied offensives that ended World War Two.