Cortland Associates Sells $10.09M of Blue Owl Shares After 40% Decline
In Q4 2025, Cortland Associates sold 645,218 Blue Owl Capital shares worth $10.09 million, after the stock fell 40% year-over-year and underperformed the S&P 500 by 56 percentage points. This follows missed earnings expectations, rising non-accruals and pending fund-withdrawal lawsuits that could weigh on its upcoming earnings report.
1. Upcoming Earnings Report and Growth Expectations
Blue Owl Capital is scheduled to release its quarterly results next week, with analysts projecting year-over-year earnings growth driven by an anticipated 12% increase in fee-related net inflows. Despite revenue forecasts climbing by roughly 8% compared to the same period last year, the firm lacks the dual catalysts—strong asset-management fee expansion and significant performance-fee recognition—that often fuel upside surprises. Investors will be closely monitoring fund performance metrics, particularly in its credit and private-equity strategies, where net new commitments stalled in the second half of fiscal 2025.
2. Significant Institutional Selling Pressure
In the fourth quarter of 2025, Cortland Associates Inc/MO divested 645,218 shares of Blue Owl stock, representing approximately $10.09 million in notional value. This transaction underscores a growing wariness among large asset managers, as Blue Owl’s shares have lagged the broader market by 56 percentage points over the past 12 months. The firm’s equity valuation has been weighed down by rising non-accrual rates within its direct lending portfolios and ongoing litigation concerning withdrawal requests in specialty finance vehicles.
3. Contrarian Perspective on Valuation Dislocation
Contrarian investors argue that pervasive negative headlines have unfairly penalized Blue Owl’s share valuation, which now trades at a double-digit discount relative to asset-management peers on a price-to-earnings basis. With fee-earning assets under management rising 5% sequentially and deposit-like balance sheet structures limiting capital‐markets volatility, proponents highlight a valuation gap that has quietly reached its widest level in five years. Long-term backtests suggest that similar spreads have historically reverted toward industry norms within 12 to 18 months.