Disney Shares 43% Below 2021 Peak as Streaming Profits Rise 39%
Disney shares trade around $114, 43% below their March 2021 high of $198.60 and lag the S&P 500’s 75% gain since Bob Iger’s 2022 return. Fiscal Q4 linear TV income fell 21% year-over-year, streaming operating profit jumped 39%, and NBA rights costs soared 73% for 2025-26.
1. Disney’s Valuation and Streaming Profit Surge Position It Ahead of Netflix
Walt Disney’s shares trade at a P/E ratio of 17.2, a substantial discount to Netflix’s 27.3 multiple, suggesting greater upside potential for long-term investors. In fiscal 2025, Disney’s direct-to-consumer streaming segment saw operating profits jump nearly tenfold, driven by robust subscriber growth on Disney+ and cost efficiencies implemented across content production and distribution. Analysts note that if Disney sustains mid-teens operating margins on streaming, its overall earnings growth trajectory could outpace that of its higher-valued peer over the next five years.
2. Shares Dip More Sharply Than Broader Market on Recent Trading Day
In the most recent trading session, Disney’s stock declined by approximately 1.9%, underperforming the broader market’s modest advance. Traders attributed the pullback to profit-taking after a multi-week rally and to concerns around near-term park attendance trends following a 1% drop in domestic gate admissions in 2025. Despite the setback, Disney’s Experiences division continues to deliver strong per-capita spending, offsetting volume pressures with strategic price increases.
3. Sluggish Stock Performance Challenges CEO Bob Iger’s Legacy
Under Bob Iger’s leadership, Disney has completed major turnarounds—streaming profitability has returned, and the company has mapped out a multi-year parks expansion—but the share price remains roughly 43% below its March 2021 high. Since Iger’s return in late 2022, Disney shares are up about 24%, compared with a roughly 75% gain for the S&P 500 over the same period. Within the firm’s three core segments, traditional TV saw linear operating income fall 21% year-over-year in the latest quarter, streaming operating income rose 39%, and sports rights costs jumped 73% with the new NBA deal. Wall Street remains focused on whether Disney can deliver steady, repeatable earnings growth in each division to restore relative performance.