Analysts Downgrade Ford To Hold After 43.6% Rally Over EV Underperformance
Ford Motor has been downgraded to hold by analysts after a 43.6% rally, citing deteriorating fundamentals and expected electric vehicle asset write-downs despite strong Q3 2025 revenue growth and cash flow. Ford’s EV sales and market share fell sharply, leaving its EV segment lagging peers as industry adoption slowed.
1. Stock Performance Relative to Peers
Ford Motor Company’s shares have climbed roughly 18.2% year-to-date through January 2026, outpacing the broader Auto-Tires-Trucks group average gain of 11.7%. During the same period, key peer Modine Holdings has returned just 4.3%. Ford’s outperformance is largely driven by stronger-than-expected demand for its gasoline-powered pickups and SUVs in North America, which accounted for 63% of the company’s $138.6 billion in 2025 revenues.
2. Upcoming Earnings Set to Surprise Street
Analysts surveyed by Refinitiv project Ford will report fourth-quarter adjusted earnings of $0.47 per share, topping the $0.39 per share delivered in Q4 2024. Consensus revenue estimates stand at $43.1 billion, up 4.8% year-over-year, supported by stable pricing on its F-150 and Explorer models. Street estimates also anticipate free cash flow of approximately $3.2 billion, reflecting ongoing cost controls in North American assembly plants.
3. EV Strategy Raises Concerns, Rating Downgraded
Following a 43.6% rally in the past twelve months, a leading research firm cut its recommendation on Ford to "Hold," citing weakening EV fundamentals. In Q3 2025, Ford reported $56 million in adjusted net profit on EV operations, down from $148 million a year earlier, and flagged potential write-downs of $1.2 billion on underperforming EV assets. EV sales fell 27% sequentially, with Ford’s share of U.S. electric pickup and SUV deliveries slipping to 8.4%.
4. Supply Chain and Safety Probes Pressure Production
Ford continues to feel the impact of a September 2025 fire at aluminum supplier Novelis, with plant output operating at roughly 60% capacity and no full resumption expected before March 2026. The shortfall has constrained F-150 production by an estimated 15,000 units in Q4 2025. Concurrently, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration expanded its investigation to cover 1.27 million F-150 pickups over reports of unexpected downshifts and rear-wheel lockup, raising costs for potential recalls and warranty repairs.