S&P 500 ETF Falls 1.5% Then Rallies 1.2%; Goldman Sees 12% Gain

SPYSPY

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust fell 1.5% Tuesday after Trump's threatened Greenland tariffs, then rebounded 1.2% on tariff withdrawal. Goldman Sachs set a 12% 2026 return target for the S&P 500, citing two 25bp Fed cuts and AI-driven 12% EPS growth despite a 22x forward P/E.

1. SPY Dips on Greenland Tariff Threats

The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) slid 1.5% on Tuesday following President Trump’s announcement of potential tariffs on European nations that opposed U.S. efforts to acquire Greenland. This decline formed part of a broader market sell‐off that saw the Magnificent Seven stocks lose over $700 billion in value in a single session, underscoring SPY’s sensitivity to geopolitical risk despite its broad diversification across the S&P 500 index.

2. Rapid Rebound After Tariff Reversal

SPY recouped most of its losses the very next day, rallying 1.2% on Wednesday after the administration quietly dropped the proposed tariff measures. The swift reversal reinforced the so‐called “buy the dip” mentality among large institutional investors, with SPY’s trading volume spiking by over 30% from its 30-day average as funds and algorithmic strategies deployed fresh capital to capitalize on the bounce.

3. Goldman Sachs’ 12% Target and Valuation Concerns

Analysts at Goldman Sachs have set a 12% upside target for the S&P 500 this year, implying a comparable gain for SPY. Their bullish case rests on two main pillars: anticipated Federal Reserve rate cuts totaling 50 basis points by year-end and a projected 12% increase in S&P 500 earnings driven by AI-related productivity gains. That said, SPY currently trades at a forward P/E near 22×—a multiple that matches the 2021 peak and approaches the 2000 record—leaving little cushion if corporate profits disappoint.

4. Pension Fund Exit Highlights Bond‐Equity Dynamics

In a sign of shifting cross‐asset sentiment, Denmark’s AkademikerPension sold its entire $100 million U.S. Treasury position, citing both U.S. fiscal deficits and recent geopolitical tensions. While the fund’s move was described as a symbolic ‘warning shot’ rather than a market‐moving event, some portfolio managers view the sale as evidence that bonds no longer offer a reliable hedge. As a result, allocations have tilted back into equities, with SPY absorbing an estimated $4 billion in net inflows over the past two weeks as investors rotate back toward stocks.

Sources

2BBBB
+1 more