Old National Bancorp Price Target Stays at $25 Despite Q4 EPS Beat and Elevated Multiples

ONBONB

Consensus price target has held at $25 versus $25.50 last quarter, supporting a Hold rating despite elevated multiples and credit-quality concerns. Old National Bancorp beat Q4 estimates with EPS of $0.59 versus $0.56, driven by Bremer and CapStar acquisitions and 83.7% insider ownership.

1. Company Overview

Old National Bancorp is a regional banking institution founded in 1834, offering a full range of retail and commercial financial services across five Midwestern states. The bank operates 162 full-service branches in Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota and Wisconsin, serving more than 550,000 customers. Its diversified business mix includes consumer lending, commercial banking, wealth management and mortgage origination, providing multiple revenue streams that have supported steady growth over the past three years.

2. Price Target Stability

Analysts have maintained a consensus price target of approximately $25 for Old National’s common shares over the past twelve months, down only marginally from $25.50 in the prior year. This narrow trading range reflects a broadly stable outlook on valuation. Despite the modest downward revision last quarter, only one major brokerage changed its target, setting $24 based on slightly elevated price multiples relative to peer group averages in regional banking.

3. Growth Drivers and Credit Quality

Old National’s revenue increased by 12% year-over-year in the most recent fiscal year, driven largely by the acquisitions of Bremer Financial and CapStar Financial Holdings. Net interest income expanded by 15% over the same period, while noninterest income rose 9%. However, credit‐quality metrics have shown a slight uptick in nonperforming assets, rising to 0.85% of total loans from 0.70% a year earlier. Analysts cite this trend, along with a price-to-tangible book value multiple near 1.8x, as factors limiting an upgrade from the current Hold ratings.

4. Earnings Performance and Stakeholder Confidence

In its latest quarter, Old National delivered $0.59 in earnings per share, surpassing the consensus estimate of $0.56 by 5%. Return on tangible common equity improved to 9.2%, up from 8.5% a year ago. The bank’s insider and institutional ownership stands at 83.7%, underscoring strong confidence from long-term shareholders. Comparative analysis indicates Old National’s dividend yield of 3.1% ranks in the top quartile among regional peers, reinforcing its appeal to income-oriented investors.

Sources

SF