Pfizer Underperforms Peers on COVID-19 Decline but Secures 3-Year Section 232 Exemption
In the last six months, Pfizer underperformed peers due to waning COVID-19 product demand and a looming patent cliff overshadowing its 2026 outlook. It secured a three-year Section 232 exemption and could gain from a dismantled PBM rebate model, strengthening its margin defense.
1. Q4 Earnings Forecast to Decline
Analysts project Pfizer’s fourth-quarter earnings per share to fall by approximately 15% year-over-year, reflecting a 45% drop in COVID-19 vaccine and therapeutic revenues compared with the same period last year. With COVID-19 product sales contributing roughly $2.5 billion in Q4 2023, the company faces a revenue shortfall that management expects will not be fully offset by its oncology and rare disease franchises. Operating expenses are anticipated to rise by nearly 5% due to continued investment in gene therapy manufacturing capacity and late-stage clinical trials for its Alzheimer’s candidate, putting further pressure on margins.
2. Comparative Underperformance in Last Six Months
Over the past six months, Pfizer’s share performance has lagged peers Merck and Johnson & Johnson by about 12 percentage points, driven primarily by waning demand for its COVID-19 products and an impending patent cliff on its hypertension blockbuster set to expire in mid-2026. In contrast, Merck’s immuno-oncology portfolio and J&J’s diversified medical device and consumer health lines have provided more stable growth. Investors have also reacted to Pfizer’s 2026 financial guidance that calls for low-single-digit revenue growth, below consensus expectations for mid-single-digit expansion in the pharmaceutical sector.
3. Regulatory Exemption Strengthens Margin Outlook
Despite regulatory headwinds proposed under the new healthcare plan, Pfizer secured a negotiated three-year exemption from Section 232 import tariffs, a carve-out not afforded to many competitors. This exemption is estimated to preserve up to $400 million annually in gross profit by shielding its vaccine and small-molecule manufacturing imports from proposed duties. Additionally, potential reforms to the pharmacy benefit manager rebate model could enhance realized net prices for Pfizer’s portfolio by an estimated 2% to 3%, reinforcing the company’s margin defense against pricing pressures in the broader market.