O’Reilly Automotive Posts 32-Year Same-Store Sales Growth, 11.4% EPS Projection

ORLYORLY

O’Reilly Automotive has delivered positive returns in nine of the past ten years and posted 32 consecutive years of same-store sales growth. Analysts project 11.4% EPS growth in 2026, while shares trade at a 32.5 P/E ratio above its five-year average.

1. Analysts Maintain Buy Consensus

O’Reilly Automotive is covered by twenty-three firms, of which nineteen carry a buy rating, two assign a strong-buy, and two recommend holding the shares. This distribution underpins a broadly positive sentiment among sell-side analysts and reflects confidence in O’Reilly’s earnings resilience and market positioning within the auto-parts aftermarket.

2. Recent Analyst Actions Highlight Upside Potential

Over the past quarter, UBS Group reiterated its buy view and lifted its target by roughly 4%, while TD Cowen boosted its objective by more than 10%. Evercore ISI reiterated an outperform stance, Baird R.W. elevated the shares to strong-buy, and Goldman Sachs maintained its buy recommendation. These revisions suggest analysts see further upside from continued same-store sales growth and effective margin management.

3. Insider Selling Signals Ownership Adjustments

During the last quarter, two directors reduced their holdings: one sold 3,125 shares (a 27.8% cut to his position) and another disposed of 2,355 shares (a 98.8% reduction). Overall, insiders offloaded 8,980 shares, representing just over 1% of total shares outstanding. Though notable, these transactions follow a broader pattern of portfolio rebalancing rather than a shift in corporate strategy.

4. Solid Q3 Results and 2025 Guidance Support Outlook

In the most recent quarter, O’Reilly reported earnings per share of $0.85, beating consensus by $0.02, on revenues up 7.8% year-over-year to $4.71 billion. The company delivered a net margin of 14.2% and an annualized return on equity above 200%, underscoring operational efficiency. Management’s full-year 2025 guidance calls for EPS between $2.90 and $3.00, reinforcing expectations for mid-single-digit revenue growth and stable profitability trends.

Sources

FD